Mayan vs Egyptian pyramids: size, age, purpose and why they look alike
Egyptian pyramids are tombs: smooth-sided, sealed, built between about 2650 and 1700 BC to hold a king's body, with the temples outside at the base. Mayan and other Mesoamerican pyramids are platforms for temples: stepped, with a staircase up the front and a shrine on top, built between about 1000 BC and AD 1500 for ceremonies performed in public view, sometimes also enclosing a royal tomb. The Great Pyramid of Giza is the tallest, but the Great Pyramid of Cholula in Mexico is the largest by volume. The two traditions are separated by an ocean and 2,500 years and grew from the same simple fact: a pile of earth or stone is the easiest way to make a mountain, and mountains are where gods live. Below: the comparison point by point, a table, the biggest and oldest of each, and the question of whether the builders ever met.
Age
Egypt first. The Step Pyramid of Djoser at Saqqara dates to about 2650 BC, the Great Pyramid to about 2560 BC, and Egyptian kings stopped building pyramids around 1700 BC; the later pyramids of Nubia, in Sudan, continued to about AD 350. The oldest pyramids in the Americas are older than most people think: the platform mounds of Caral in Peru date to about 2600 BC, contemporary with Giza, and the Olmec earthen pyramid at La Venta to about 900 BC. The Maya themselves built from about 300 BC; the famous ones, Tikal (about AD 740), Palenque (683) and Chichen Itza (about 1000), are between 3,000 and 3,300 years younger than the Great Pyramid. When the Spanish arrived in 1519 the Aztecs were still building.
Size
By height Egypt wins: the Great Pyramid was 481 feet (146.6 m) and is now 454 feet; Khafre's is 448 feet. The tallest in the Americas is the Pyramid of the Sun at Teotihuacan at 216 feet (66 m), and the tallest Maya pyramid, Temple IV at Tikal, is 230 feet (70 m). By volume the answer flips: the Great Pyramid of Cholula near Puebla, Mexico, measures about 1,480 feet (450 m) on each side and 217 feet (66 m) high, roughly 4.45 million cubic metres against Giza's 2.5 million, making it the largest pyramid and the largest monument ever built. It looks like a hill with a church on top because it was built of adobe brick over many centuries and had grown over with soil before the Spanish came.
Purpose
An Egyptian pyramid is a machine for a single burial. The king's chamber is inside or beneath the mass, sealed after the funeral; the daily cult happened in a mortuary temple against the east face, connected by a causeway to a valley temple by the Nile. Nothing was meant to happen on the pyramid itself. A Mesoamerican pyramid is a stage. The temple is a small building on the summit, reached by a steep stair up the front, and the ceremonies, offerings, incense, bloodletting and, at some periods and places, human sacrifice, were performed at the top for crowds in the plaza below. Many were also tombs: the Temple of the Inscriptions at Palenque holds the sarcophagus of King Pakal deep inside, found in 1952, and Tikal's Temple I covers the tomb of Jasaw Chan K'awiil. So the Maya combined both functions, and the Egyptians kept them apart.
Shape and construction
- Sides. Egyptian pyramids after Djoser are true pyramids with smooth casing and a single point; the steps visible today at Giza are the core exposed after the casing was stripped. Mesoamerican pyramids are stepped platforms, usually with several sloping tiers, a flat top and one or more staircases.
- Material. Egypt: solid limestone core blocks of 2.5 tons, granite chambers, fine limestone casing, mostly built in one reign. Mesoamerica: a rubble-and-earth core faced with cut stone and lime plaster, painted red, built in layers, each king wrapping the last pyramid in a larger one; Tikal, Chichen Itza and Cholula all have earlier pyramids inside.
- Interior. Egypt: passages and chambers designed from the start. Mesoamerica: usually solid, with tombs cut into the base or the earlier structure; the tunnels used by archaeologists are modern.
- Alignment. Giza's sides face the cardinal points to within a fifteenth of a degree. Maya pyramids align to sunrise on particular days: at El Castillo the equinox sun casts a serpent of shadow down the north stair, and its 365 steps make a calendar.
- Tools. Neither civilization had iron or the wheel for transport. Egypt used copper tools and sledges over wet sand; the Maya used stone tools, tumplines and human porters, with no draught animals at all.
Comparison table
- Dates. Egypt about 2650–1700 BC (Nubia to AD 350) vs Mesoamerica about 1000 BC–AD 1520.
- Tallest. Great Pyramid of Giza, 481 feet, vs Temple IV at Tikal, 230 feet.
- Largest by volume. Cholula, 4.45 million m³, vs Giza, 2.5 million m³.
- Purpose. Royal tomb vs temple platform, sometimes also a tomb.
- Shape. Smooth true pyramid vs stepped platform with stairs and a summit shrine.
- Construction. One campaign in solid stone vs layers over centuries, rubble core faced with stone and plaster.
- Access. Sealed after burial vs climbed daily by priests.
- Number. About 120 in Egypt and 250 in Sudan vs thousands across Mexico and Central America.
Were they connected?
No. The similarity is the obvious solution to the same problem. Any culture that wants a tall, permanent structure without iron, cranes or arches ends up with a wide base and sloping sides, because that is the shape a pile takes; the ziggurats of Mesopotamia, the pyramids of Sudan, the tumuli of China and the temple mounds of the Mississippi valley all found it independently. The proposals that Egyptians, Phoenicians or Atlanteans crossed the Atlantic go back to the 19th century and Ignatius Donnelly; they founder on the dates (the Maya pyramids are millennia later), on the absence of any Old World plant, animal, tool, script or disease in the Americas before 1492, and on the differences in shape and use listed above. Thor Heyerdahl's 1970 reed-boat crossing showed such a voyage was physically possible, not that it happened. Trans-oceanic contact theories.
The ones to know
Egypt: the Pyramid of Djoser, the Great Pyramid, the Pyramid of Khafre, Menkaure, the Bent and Red Pyramids of Dahshur. Mesoamerica: El Castillo and the Temple of the Warriors at Chichen Itza, Tikal, Palenque, Uxmal, Calakmul, Copán, and outside the Maya area the Pyramid of the Sun, Cholula, El Tajín and the Aztec Templo Mayor. How the Egyptian ones were raised is in how the pyramids were built; the Mexican city that built the Pyramid of the Sun is in who built Teotihuacan.
Open the sections: ancient temples of the world, buildings by style, all articles.
Short answers
Which are bigger, Mayan or Egyptian pyramids?
Egyptian pyramids are taller: the Great Pyramid is 481 feet against 230 feet for the tallest Maya temple at Tikal. But the Great Pyramid of Cholula in Mexico is larger by volume than any Egyptian pyramid and is the largest monument ever built.
Which are older, Mayan or Egyptian pyramids?
Egyptian, by about 2,500 years for the famous ones: Giza dates to about 2560 BC, the classic Maya pyramids to AD 600–1000. The earliest American platform mounds at Caral in Peru, though, are as old as Giza.
What was the difference in purpose?
Egyptian pyramids were sealed tombs with the temple outside at the base; Mesoamerican pyramids were platforms with a temple on top for public ceremonies, and some also held a royal tomb inside.
Did the Egyptians teach the Maya to build pyramids?
No. There is no Old World object, plant, animal, script or disease in the Americas before 1492, the dates are millennia apart, and the shapes and uses differ; both cultures arrived at the pyramid because it is the natural shape of a tall pile.